|
|
Ofcom seem to have hit a brick wall in enforcing its censorship rules on US companies without a presence in the UK
|
|
|
|
21st October 2026
|
|
|
See Committee questions for Ofcom from parliamentlive.tv See
article from order-order.com See
article from prestonbyrne.com
|
Ofcom were grilled by Parliament's Culture, Media and Sport Committee on 20th October 2026. The committee is investigated the effectiveness of Ofcom in enforcing internet censorship laws contained in the Online Safety Act. The act has been in force
for about 15 months and in that time Ofcom have issued 11 fines mostly to porn websites for failing to implement ID/age verification. Other websites targeted were the US based free speech forum 4Chan, and also the widely reviled Sanctioned Suicide forum.
Ofcom boss Melanie Dawes admitted that tech firms have paid just the two smallest of the eleven fines handed out under the Online Safety Act since March last year. She conceded nine remain unpaid, albeit one of these has not yet passed its due date
and another is being appealed. She did point out that two of the nine have now implemented the required ID/age verification and four have self geo-blocked all users with a UK IP address. Three are totally defying Ofcom by continuing on unchanged.
Dawes added that enforcement measures have run against a brick wall for foreign companies without a presence in the UK. She said: We won't be able to recover every single fine on online safety. If foreign courts
decide try and get in our way, there will be a point at which we have to accept that we won't be able to recover that money.
The US lawyer representing some of the US victims of the censorship law Preston Byrne had been particularly
vocal about Ofcom's censorship attempts by shredding Ofcom's censorship letters and using them at hamster litter. He continually challenged Ofcom to fight him in the US courts where the famous First Amendment to the US Constitutions guarantees free
speech for all Americans. Byrne colourfully explains:
Unless Ofcom is prepared to sail a British invasion fleet here and land ground troops, enforcement would indeed have to proceed through American courts. Which presents the following problem for Ofcom: American courts generally
decline to enforce foreign judgments that violate the United States Constitution. It would be a gift to 4chan if Ofcom decided to show up in an American court after all this, waiving sovereign immunity and thus facing the prospect
of an adverse merits ruling in the process. Filing that lawsuit would be suicidal, leading to virtually certain defeat and total loss of enforcement credibility in the United States. It will almost certainly never happen, not for 4chan, and likely not
for any other American target, either. What will happen next is that Ofcom is going to go back to Parliament to ask for the authority to obtain interim business disruption measures -- i.e., more or less unilateral censorship
powers to block foreign websites in the UK before starting an enforcement process, rather than after. These powers were explicitly rejected by Parliament the last time around and have even now been repudiated by Nadine Dorries, the former MP who
introduced the Bill, having seen what a mess Ofcom has made of it. These powers will also be easily defeated through the use of a VPN. The UK thus continues its authoritarian backsliding. Sorting out their own country is,
ultimately, a matter for the British, and opposing the grant of new powers for Ofcom -- an agency which was held off by a pair of American solo lawyers working for free -- on domestic policy grounds is a task for the growing UK free speech movement to
take up, with urgency.
Ofcom bosses also explained to the parliamentary committee that geo-blocking UK users from access to website is as far as censorship actions can go. If a website self-geo-blocks there is little point pursing an
ISP block as that effectively adds nothing further to the censorship. UK VPN users will still be able to access the website either way.
|
|
|
The UK government announces that commonplace porn scenes will be illegal to publish or to own, but seemingly not to stream
|
|
|
|
16th October 2026
|
|
|
See press release from gov.uk
|
From 6 November 2026, it will be a criminal offence in England and Wales to possess or publish pornographic images that explicitly and realistically depict:
strangulation or suffocation penetrative sexual activity between people who a reasonable person would think are related, or pretending to be related, in a certain way. This includes depictions of close
familial relatives such as father and daughter or brother and sister, and certain step and foster relationships where one person is, or is pretending to be, under 18 sexual activity between at least 2 people where a
reasonable person would think at least one person is, or is pretending to be, under 16
The offences only capture pornography that shows people which appear, to a reasonable person, to be real. The maximum penalty for possession is:
2 years' imprisonment for pornography that depicts strangulation or suffocation, or penetrative sexual activity between certain relatives; 3 years' imprisonment for pornography depicting sexual
activity involving a person who is, or is pretending to be, under 16
The maximum penalty for publication for all offences is 5 years' imprisonment. There are defences available for these offences. For example, a person may have a defence to the possession and publication
offences if they had not seen the image before and did not know, or have cause to suspect, that it was an image covered by the offences. There is also a defence where the person who possesses or publishes the image directly
participated in the act shown in the image and other criteria are met. For the possession offences, there is also a defence where a person was sent the image without asking for it (either themselves, or through a third party) and did not keep it for an
unreasonable length of time. The offences also attract a defence of legitimate reason for possessing or publishing the image. What we mean by possession and publication The term
possess is not defined in the legislation and will be given its ordinary meaning. Whether a person possesses an image will be a question of fact for the court in each case. However, we consider that possessing an image will generally mean having custody
or control of it. This could include where an image is stored on a device, retained in a personal account or cloud, saved in files, or otherwise kept physically or virtually. Publish is defined in the offences to include giving or
making an image available to another person by any means. This could include uploading, posting, sending, sharing or distributing an image. What we mean by strangulation and suffocation The term strangulation is not defined in the
legislation and will be given its ordinary meaning. Whether an image depicts strangulation will be a question of fact for the court in each case. We consider that strangulation generally means one person applying pressure to another person's neck.
The term suffocation is not defined in the legislation and will be given its ordinary meaning. Whether an image depicts suffocation will be a question of fact for the court in each case. We consider that suffocation will generally
mean depriving a person of air in a way that affects their ability to breathe. Unlike strangulation, this does not require pressure to the neck. It could, for example, involve covering someone's mouth and nose or compressing their chest.
What you need to do before 6 November 2026 Possession is a continuing act. If you already possess an image covered by these offences, you will need to permanently delete it or otherwise get rid of it before 6
November 2026 to avoid committing an offence once the offences come into force. Publication can also be a continuing act. If you have uploaded, posted or otherwise made an image covered by these offences available whether online
or offline, you will need to remove it and stop making it available to others before 6 November 2026. If you possess or are continuing to publish an image covered by these offences, you must stop doing so before they come into
force. This means if you possess it, you need to permanently delete it or otherwise get rid of it before commencement. If you are continuing to publish it (whether online or offline), you need to remove it and stop publication before commencement.
|
|
|
BBFC given feasibility study into censoring worldwide internet porn
|
|
|
|
16th October 2026
|
|
|
See article from news.sky.com
|
The government has commissioned British Board of Film Censorship to test the feasibility of censoring online pornography for violent and abusive content. The pilot by the BBFC will inform ministerial decisions on the most effective way to censor world
wide websites potentially resulting in a formal online censor. A government commissioned review by anti porn peer Gabby Bertin has resulted in new criminal offences for the publication and possession of certain types of online pornography,
including strangulation, incest, step-incest and adults role-playing as children. The laws will come into force by the 6th November. However Baroness Bertin said for the legislation to be effective there also needed to be more proactive
regulation, including spot checking and auditing. Bertin's review had suggested the BBFC audit websites, given its experience monitoring offline pornography for 40 years. They have previously raised concerns about the disparity between online and
offline regulation and said they stand ready to expand their remit. They were awarded a three-month contract for an Audit of Internet Services pilot in July. The pilot includes generating evidence on the availability of certain online pornographic
content and evaluating how it could be monitored and reported on at scale given the huge size of the market. Such a porn censor would need funding for staff to monitor content as well as new technology. Baroness Bertin proposed a model where porn
companies as well as social media companies and search engines pay for it. Bertin suggested that users would appreciate a BBFC censored website saying: You are then saying to users, we are tried and tested and if
you come into our site you won't see illegal content.
She said as well as monitoring for illegal content, an auditor could draw up guidance to address the grey area of material that is not illegal but would be banned in the offline
world. It could also do spot checks for age of performers and consent, and help bring down sites that are not behind an age gate or are showing illegal content - either through having its own statutory powers or working alongside Ofcom. Ofcom has
the power to fines sites that don't comply with new age verification requirements that came into force last year as part of the Online Safety Act, but Baroness Bertin said the system is too slow. It should also be noted that only a couple of websites
have actually paid Ofcom fines.
|
|
|
US Congressman introduces a bill 'Guaranteeing Rights Against Novel International Tyranny and Extortion'
|
|
|
|
9th September 2026
|
|
|
29th August 2026 See article from freespeechunion.org See
bill[pdf] from congress.gov
|
A Republican congressman and ally of President Trump, Michael Rulli, has filed a bill that would prevent the British internet censor Ofcom from enforcing Orwellian online safety rules on websites based in the US. This landmark bill would also prevent US
courts from recognising or enforcing foreign fines relating to online speech. Since Donald Trump returned to the presidency, he and his administration have been fiercely critical of the UK Government's approach to free speech, particularly online,
repeatedly citing the Online Safety Act. These concerns are also levelled at the EU for its Digital Services Act. In the eyes of the US administration, these censorious legislative regimes have infringed not only on the free speech of British and
European citizens, but also on the First Amendment rights of US citizens, while unfairly targeting American businesses. The bill introduced by Congressman Rulli is called the Granite Act (Guaranteeing Rights Against Novel International Tyranny and
Extortion). Speaking to The Times, Rulli said: F Foreign bureaucrats do not get to decide what Americans can say. My bill makes clear that if a foreign government tries to punish an American for speech protected by
the First Amendment, that judgment is dead on arrival in our courts. Ofcom has repeatedly gone after US websites for alleged breaches of the Online Safety Act, notably 4chan and Kiwi Farms. In March, Ofcom fined 4chan a staggering
£520,000 after finding that it had failed to comply with its duties under the Act. Both 4chan and Kiwi Farms have launched legal action in the US seeking an injunction against Ofcom. The regulator responded by asking for the case to be dismissed,
arguing that, as a foreign governmental body, it was protected,claiming sovereign immunity, from being sued under US law. Rulli's bill would remove that protection. It is not expected that this particular version of the bill will make it onto the
statute book, but with support from a number of key Trump officials, the House Judiciary Committee, and the backing of both the White House and State Department, similar proposals could be taken forward. The wording of the bill reads:
LIMITATION ON ENFORCEMENT OF FOREIGN CENSORSHIP JUDGMENTS. (a) LIMITATION ON ENFORCEMENT Notwithstanding any other provision of Federal or State law, a domestic court shall not recognize
or enforce a foreign judgment, or a fine, order, or demand issued by a foreign court or a foreign state, enforcing a foreign censorship law. (b) RIGHT OF ACTION A United States person against whom a foreign
judgment described in subsection (a) is entered, or upon whom a judgment, fine, order, or demand described in subsection (a) is served or purportedly served, may bring an action in an appropriate district court of the United States seeking declaratory
relief that such judgment, fine, order, or demand is unenforceable under subsection (a) Update: Another bill opposing foreign censorship from the likes of Ofcom 9th September 2026.See
article from prestonbyrne.com by Preston Byrne
US Representative Warren Davidson has introduced the HOMEFRONT Act , the Halting Overseas Mandates from Extraterritorially Reaching Onto National Territory Act. The HOMEFRONT Act is a GRANITE-style foreign censorship shield
bill, the seventh such GRANITE-architecture bill or model policy to be advanced by American legislators in the last seven months, and the third such bill to be advanced in the last ten days. I anticipate there will be even more GRANITE-style bills, both
state and federal, in the next several months. In terms of where HOMEFRONT fits into the new, but rapidly-growing, ten-month-old American tradition of foreign censorship shield bills, many of Rep. Davidsons additional provisions
hew closely to the original Wyoming GRANITE Act proposal introduced by Rep. Daniel Singh in that state earlier this year. There are also some novel provisions which have never been seen in the foreign censorship shield discourse before today.
Between the two bills, Rep. Davidsons bill is the more detailed and the more aggressive. Its private cause of action -- its sword -- includes damages language and would, if enacted, have greater deterrent effect than a
declaration-only bill. Much of what Rullis bill implies is, in Davidsons proposal, made express. Eeither bill is a dramatic improvement over the present state of affairs and, as a lawyer working in the area of foreign censorship
defense, on the ground, either bill, if enacted, would be most useful to that work. Any legislator concerned about the fact that Americans are being threatened by foreign governments over our constitutionally protected expression could, quite safely,
vote for either one.
|
|
|