|
Porn sites in France suffer setbacks after losing court cases
|
|
|
 |
15th January 2023
|
|
| See article
from numerama.com |
Notable porn websites operating in France have suffered two legal defeats. In the first case, a priority question of constitutionality (QPC) had been addressed to the Court of Cassation. MindGeek, which publishes Pornhub, argued that ISP blocking of
their websites, as ordered by France's internet censors of the Audiovisual and Digital Communication Regulatory Authority (Arcom), was an affront to freedom of speech in France. In its verdict of January 5, the Court of Cassation swept aside this
QPC: The question posed is not of a serious nature. Considering that the legal framework in question is sufficiently clear and precise to exclude any risk of arbitrariness . Nor is there any disproportionate harm to the
objectives pursued. The attack on freedom of expression, by imposing the use of a device for verifying the age of the person accessing pornographic content, other than a simple declaration of majority, is necessary, appropriate
and proportionate to the objective of protecting minors.
Meanwhile YouPorn and RedTube lost an administrative challenge to the rather circuitous way that French authorities have specified the laws requiring age/identity verification
to view porn websites. |
|
France announces a global initiative on child protection that includes identity/age verification for all
|
|
|
| 13th November 2022
|
|
| See article from
reclaimthenet.org |
The French government has announced a global initiative for online child safety. The purpose of the Children Online Protection Laboratory is to incentivize researchers, campaigners, and tech giants to come up with measures to best protect children
online. Tech giants Google , Amazon, Meta, and TikTok , as well as Dailymotion said they will sign a charter. In the first year, the participants of the Child Protection Laboratory will focus on developing systems for detecting sexual
predators posing as minors and a shared database to detect and remove explicit images shared non-consensually. However, the other aspects of the proposal include looking into online age verification, a move that could restrict online privacy for all
users. In the past few years, Macron's government has pushed for reforms in online child safety. However, some of the efforts have not been successful. For instance, the legislation requiring adult websites to verify age has not been enforced, yet it
was passed over two years ago. The highest court in the country, the Cour de Cassation has until January to rule on whether the Constitutional Council should review if the age verification rules violate the Constitution and if they are a major threat to
privacy in the country. |
|
French courts try to find an acceptable method of age verification for porn
|
|
|
| 11th September 2022
|
|
| See article from 20minutes.fr
|
A Paris court has offered to organize a mediation to find a way to prevent minors from accessing pornography on the internet. Campaigners had asked telecom operators to immediately block several porn websites but French law does not actually specify
how this should be achieved. The decision to order the parties to negotiate will be formally taken soon as the French internet censor ARCOM does not seem willing or able to specify how age verification should be done. The Cypriot company MG
Freesit es, publisher of the Pornhub platform, one of the five sites targeted in this procedure, for its part filed a priority question of constitutionality (QPC) which calls into question the legitimacy of Arcom to act. The court will decide on
October 4 whether or not to send this QPC to the Court of Cassation. If this was not the case, a new civil hearing would be organized to examine the case on the merits. During the debates, the lawyers representing Pornhub, Tukif, XHamster,
Xvideos, Xnxx, targeted in December 2021 by a formal notice from Arcom and which are among the most visited sites in France, tried to prove their goodwill. " None of the technical solutions that we have tested have proven to be satisfactory. Recent reports from the Cnil and Peren, the government's center of expertise in data protectin, have recalled the risks associated with existing majority verification solutions offered by the industry, while by paving the way for a system based on trusted third parties.
|
|
French court rejects request to force ISP blocking of major porn websites
|
|
|
 |
25th May 2022
|
|
| See article from xbiz.com See
article from hitechwiki.com |
A Paris appeals court has rejected requests to block the most popular adult tube sites in the country. Following months of statements and threats pressuring tube sites to implement undefined age verification schemes, French media censor ARCOM went to
court in March and April to demand that French ISPs block Pornhub, xHamster, xVideos, Cliphunter and Xnxx. Meanwhile 2 morality campaign groups are also pushing for ISP blocking via the courts, and their blocking requests add YouPorn, RedTube and
Tukif to the list. ARCOM had sent formal notices to tube site operators demanding they find a more robust solution than the simple declaration of age. The porn sites did not comply, seemingly because ARCOM had not defined what age
verification methods would be acceptable. French reports now reveal that the Council of State, an appeals court, issued a ruling rejecting the ARCOM blocking requests. The reasons for the rejection are not wholly clear so far but the most
plausible is that recourse to blocking should be the last resort rather than the first call. It seems that ARCOM should be doing more work to define what age verification measures the porn websites should be taking. |
|
French censors bang the table demanding age verification but there are no data protection laws in place that protect porn users from being tracked and scammed
|
|
|
 | 9th March 2022
|
|
| See article from
lefigaro.fr |
Pornhub, Pornhub, XHamster, XNXX and XVideos do not comply with French rules contrived from a law against domestic violence. The French internet censor Arcom (previously CSA) took legal action on March 8 and requested the blocking of 5 pornographic
sites: Pornhub, Pornhub, XHamster, Xnxx and Xvideos. The censor sent an injunction to the platforms and left 15 days to comply with the law. The websites did not comply. Since the vote on the law against domestic violence in 2020, an amendment
specifies that sites can no longer be satisfied with asking Internet users to declare that they are of legal age by clicking on a simple box. Depending on the judge's decision, ISPs will be forced or not to block access to the incriminated sites. In
case of blocking, visitors to the pornographic site will be redirected to a dedicated Arcom page. Distributors of pornographic content are therefore required, in theory, to check the age of their visitors. But how? There is currently no legally
defined method to achieve this. The censor itself has never given guidelines to the platforms. In fact data protection authorities have rather put a spanner in the works that has left the industry scratching its head. In an opinion issued on June 3,
2021, the National Commission for Computing and Freedoms (Cnil) decreed that a verification system which collects information on the identity of Internet users would, in this context, be illegal and risky. Such data collection would indeed present
significant risks for the persons concerned since their sexual orientation -- real or supposed -- could be deduced from the content viewed and directly linked to their identity. Faced with these legal contradictions, Senator Marie Mercier, rapporteur
for the amendment, has simply banged the table harder: I don't want to know how they are doing, but they have to find a solution . The law is the law.
Porn tube websites have explained their reluctance
to implement. The option to use third-party verifiers may prove very expensive for a business model based on a high number of users making up for low advertising income per users. An estimate denied by the Tukif site, says that the cost of a verification
service goes from 0.0522c to 0.222c per user, a cost to be multiplied by their 650,0000 unique daily visitors. It is presumed that many porn users will be very reluctant to hand over dangerous ID proof to porn websites so blocking the entry of
some audiences, while discouraging others will lead to collapsing income. The websites also note that as the regulator hasn't attempted to block all porn tube sites then users will be more likely to swap to unrestricted websites rather than submit
to ID verification on those website mandated to do so. |
|
France court decides not to order that ISPs block 9 major porn websites
|
|
|
 | 9th
October 2021
|
|
| See article from france24.com
|
A French court on Friday, has rejected a claim brought by two children's campaigns calling for the blocking of major porn websites in France. The judge rejected the claim because the court facing time pressures had not been able to hear arguments from
the sites' publishers. The anti-porn campaigners had hoped for the blocking of nine top porn sites, including PornHub and Xvideos. One of the ISPs being asked to censor the porn, Orange, noted that it already offered tools such as parental
controls to limit children's access to online pornography. Samuel Comblez of e-Enfance, one of the children's campaigners, said: It's not a completely lost battle, adding that it was now examining other ways to restrict access to the sites.
|
|
Children's campaigners take legal action to force French ISPs to block major porn sites
|
|
|
 | 4th
September 2021
|
|
| See article from
xbiz.com |
Two French campaign groups are suing the main ISPs in France, demanding the total block of several adult sites that they consider too accessible to minors. The groups suing top French ISPs SFR, Orange, Bouygues Télécom, Free, Colt Technologies
Services and Outre mer Télécomare are called e-Enfance (e-Infancy) and La Voix de l'Enfant (The Voice of the Child). The ISPs were asked to appear next Thursday, September 9 in front of the Paris Judicial Court. The lawsuit is proof that
the French anti-porn groups intend to restrict access to adult content in that European market. Earlier this year, supporters of France's controversial age-verification law had claimed that they knew it was impractical and considered the passage of the
measure as "symbolic." ISP Orange told Le Figaro that they will "abide by the decision of the court and would shut down these sites speedily if that's what we are asked to do. But in the absence of a judicial decision, we apply the
rules of net neutrality and freedom of expression" |
|
France passes intern porn censorship laws similar to those that failed in the UK
|
|
|
 | 10th July 2020
|
|
| See article from
arstechnica.com See article from politico.eu |
The French parliament has agreed a new law requiring age verification on pornographic websites to prevent access by children under 18. The censorship law has the support of President Emmanuel Macron, who called for such a measure in January. The
French law gives sites discretion to decide how to perform that age verification. The law gives French regulators the power to create a blacklist for overseas sites that don't comply with the new rules. If a site doesn't respond to a warning from
French officials, they can ask the Paris Court of Justice to send an order to telecom operators to block the access to these sites from France. A major sticking point in the UK's failed age verification law was privacy. Critics pointed out that it
wasn't a great idea to force adult consumers to turn over their credit card numbers to porn sites that might not have the strongest privacy protections. It's not clear what privacy protections will be offered to consumers under the French law. In
order to enforce the law, the French audiovisual regulator CSA will be granted new powers to audit and sanction companies that do not comply -- sanctions could go as far as blocking access to the websites in France with a court order. The Senate
has already voted on the bill. Following an agreement between senators and lawmakers from the lower house National Assembly, a final vote will be held again in the Senate where the bill is expected to pass. |
|
A detailed look at France's proposals requiring age verification to access porn
|
|
|
 | 15th June 2020
|
|
| See article from bits.decoded.legal |
|
|
More reforms from Macron as he gives porn websites 6 months to introduce parental control or else legislation will follow
|
|
|
 | 2nd January 2020
|
|
| See article from evangelicalfocus.com
|
French President Emmanuel Macron has said that he will legislate if necessary to get parental controls in place to block kids from porn. He said in a speech to UNESCO: We do not take a 13-year-old boy to a sex-shop, not
anything goes in the digital world. We will clarify in the penal code that the simple fact of declaring one's age online is not a strong enough protection against access to pornography by minors. The
measure will give the websites a period of six months to set up parental control by default . I know it hurts a lot of platforms, a lot of digital operators, but if in six months we have no solution, we will pass a law for automatic parental control.
Macron's reference to age 13 is not casual, because that is reportedly the average age of access to erotic content for the first time in France. |
| |